Chicago: Winnipeg of the South!

Chicago: Winnipeg of the South!

Most Manitobans would consider Jonathon Toews and the Chicago Blackhawks the crowning cultural exchange between the windy cities. But many are also aware that Winnipeg has often been referred to as the Chicago of the North. To understand why, we need to look back more than 100 years.

Both cities were rapidly expanding prairie metropolises built as much on optimism and corruption as a real economy. Their economies were both based on real estate, transportation hubs, and warehousing sites for the growing populations of the rural west. Chicago did grow much larger and earlier than Winnipeg, but our fair city expected to do the same thing, just a bit later. Our fantastic Legislative Building, the Shoal Lake aqueduct, and an architectural building boom all held out the promise of bigger and better (but mostly bigger) things to come. Huge numbers of immigrants flooded the city.

That was over 5 generations ago, almost too remote to recall, and Winnipeg has since the mid-1910s meandered down its own path.

On a recent trip to Chicago I was faced with concrete reminders of that early boom period in many ways, mostly in the form of historic architecture. Architect John Danley Atchison worked in Winnipeg from 1905-1923, and he was responsible for a number of buildings that still stand in Winnipeg. An American educated at the newly founded Chicago Institute of Art in the early 1890s, Atchison was a student of some of the key figures in the so-called “Chicago School of Architecture”, and worked in the famous firm of Jenney and Mundie before coming to Winnipeg. On a walking tour of the early skyscrapers of Chicago, I noticed a number of parallels between that work and Atchison’s buildings in Winnipeg.

The front of a multistoried neo-Gothic building in sand-coloured stone with three large windows on each story. Pedestrians walk or bike past in front.

The Fisher Building in downtown Chicago was constructed in the neo-Gothic style by D.H. Burnham and Company in 1896. A skyscraper in a similar style was built by Atchison’s employers Jenney and Mundie at about the same time.

A neo-Gothic building entrance in light cream stone with a tall arched doorway.

The neo-Gothic Curry Building near Portage and Main displays a remarkably similar entrance to the Fisher Building. Atchison designed this building in 1915 to house five floors, but due to a slowdown in the economy only two floors were built.

Looking up the side of a skyscraper full or windows, with alternating flat and bay windows.

Terracotta was a fired clay sheathing used to fireproof the building. It was available in a gleaming white, as in the Burnham and Co. Sante Fe building in Chicago (1904).

A tall building of white stone, with a rounded end on the left.

Atchison’s Union Trust Building on Main and Lombard is also clad in white glazed terracotta. It was completed in 1912 and to this day is conspicuous in its particular location.

A four-petaled decorative panel in a copper-colour.

This decorative element was designed by the famous Louis Sullivan for the Eli B. Felsenthal Store, Chicago, 1905.

An ornamental wall decoration in a cream Terracotta design.

Atchison designed the Fairchild Building in 1907 as a warehouse, but in a distinctly modern Chicago style. Terracotta decorations mimic those of Sullivan.

Dr. Roland Sawatzky

Dr. Roland Sawatzky

Curator of History

Roland Sawatzky joined The Manitoba Museum in 2011. He received his B.A. in Anthropology from the University of Winnipeg, M.A. in Anthropology from the University of South Carolina, and Ph.D. in Archaeology…
Meet Dr. Roland Sawatzky

Hey – Who’s that Mann?

There are two new exhibits opening this summer in our Parklands/Mixed Woods Gallery here at the Manitoba Museum and we couldn’t be more excited to soon be able to share our work! The Conservation lab has been working hard these past few months to get everything documented, cleaned, and mounted for its grand debut, including a very important Mann. Yes, this Mann was in fact a man, more fully known as William Mann, William Pennefather or Chief Kakekapenais, who signed Treaty No. 1 at Lower Fort Gary on behalf of the Fort Alexander Band (now Sagkeeng First Nation).

An original photographic silver-gelatin print of William Mann taken around the same time as the signing of Treaty No. 1 in 1871 was recently acquired by the Museum; however, the condition of the photograph was quite poor. As the Manitoba Museum is on Treaty No. 1 land, it is important for us to display such a prominent figure and significant artifact in our galleries; but to ensure its long term preservation, it first required a careful touch from our conservators before it could be hung on the wall.

Smoke, water, and mould damage, as well as acidic backing materials and pollutants in the air causing the photograph to have a mirrored finish, were all contributors to the poor condition of the Mann photograph. The frame was also very dirty and had numerous areas of broken plaster molding. So we said – hey, let’s fix it all!

But with many artifacts there are challenges a conservator faces and this artefact proved to be one of them. As much as we want to be able to clean and revive artifacts to their former glory, sometimes certain conditions do not make it possible. After several spot tests on the front of the photograph it was found that we wouldn’t be able to clean it without risking more damage to the emulsion (the photo-sensitive side of a photograph). In this case the best thing to do was nothing!

The cleaning and repair of its original frame proved to be much more successful. After swabs and swabs of grime were removed and the gaps filled, the frame looks like a million bucks. We re-matted the photograph with acid free materials for its long term care and at the end – to our complete surprise – the features and contrasts in the photograph actually became more visible, even though we hadn’t intervened at all. Sometimes prevention is the best form of conservation.

With a few more weeks to go before this new exhibit opens, I have provided a few before and after images of the Mann photograph as a sneak peak of what changes are coming to our galleries.

A sepia toned formal photograph of a serious-faced man, seated against a faint backdrop and where a military-style coat. The photograph is in a ornate wooden frame. Both frame and photograph look aged, and a little worn and torn. The matte around the photograph has aged to a greenish colour.

The Mann photo before treatment.

A sepia toned formal photograph of a serious-faced man, seated against a faint backdrop and where a military-style coat. The photograph is in a ornate wooden frame. The frame and glass have been cleaned, and the matte replaced with a fresh white one, making the features and contrasts of the image clearer.

The photo after treatment.

Carolyn Sirett

Carolyn Sirett

Senior Conservator

Carolyn Sirett received her B.A. in Anthropology from the University of Manitoba, Diploma in Cultural Resource Management from the University of Victoria, and Diploma in Collections Conservation and Management…
Meet Carolyn Sirett

How do I love the prairie? Let me count the ways!

Once again I will be spending a few weeks out at the Nature Conservancy of Canada’s fescue prairie preserves, south of Riding Mountain National Park, studying plant-pollinator interactions. Last week was my first trip of the year. Before I left the city I was feeling apprehensive: were the mosquitoes going to be bad, would I get Lyme disease from a tick bite, eaten by a bear, stuck in the mud? However, all that nervousness melted away as I came to my first plot and remembered what it is I love about doing field work:

5. Doing the tick flick.

A hand poised to flick one of two ticks off of knee of the person's light coloured pants.

All the ticks at the Elk Glen preserve would line up on Dr. Robson’s knee for one of her famous airplane rides (thanks for the idea for that caption Gary Larson!).

There’s nothing more satisfying than capturing a tick, putting it on your knee and flicking it into the stratosphere with your fingers (take that you lousy parasite!)

4. The view.

A striking orange dragonfly, low to the ground among dried grass.

There were tonnes of cool dragonflies to look at this spring.

In Winnipeg my office window faces a parking lot (which I think used to be paradise). Out on the prairie I get to look at leaves trembling in the breeze, colourful wildflowers and funky dragonflies.

3. Getting to know the neighbours.

A chunky woodchuck near a compact blue car parked on the grass.

The woodchuck that lives under the field house was inspecting my car.

I love the look on animals’ faces when they know they’re being watched. I startled a thirteen-lined ground squirrel, a family of Canada geese, a chipmunk, a skunk, a woodchuck and a black bear this trip. I’m just sorry I didn’t have a telephoto lens on my camera to capture their priceless expressions of shock!

2. That prairie smell of chokecherry flowers, crushed wild bergamot leaves, and dried grass.

A small shrub (chokecherry) with a few clusters of small white flowers.

Chokecherry (Prunus virginiana) flowers smell amazing!

If only I could bottle it and sell it.

An expanse of prairie grassland with a distant tree line composed of mainly aspens and evergreens.

1. The lack of noise, noise, noise, noise!

When you live in the city you get used to the noise, although it still irritates you on some level. What I hate most about the city are gas powered lawn mowers. Constantly. And always just as you sit down on your deck to read a book. When I go to the preserve the almost complete absence of human-caused noise makes me feel like I don’t want to throttle someone anymore.

 

Somewhat regretfully I am back in noisy Winnipeg, staring at that parking lot again. And ironically this morning my neighbour fired up his gas mower just as I sat on my deck to have my coffee. But in just a few more weeks I’ll be listening to those lovely mourning doves again and smelling the roses, quite literally as they should be in bloom by the time I get there. Till then, that thought will have to sustain me.

 

Image: The sound of trembling aspen (Populus tremuloides) leaves in the breeze is sublime.

Dr. Diana Bizecki Robson

Dr. Diana Bizecki Robson

Curator of Botany

Dr. Bizecki Robson obtained a Master’s Degree in Plant Ecology at the University of Saskatchewan studying rare plants of the mixed grass prairies. After working as an environmental consultant and sessional lecturer…
Meet Dr. Bizecki Robson